View Single Post
  #13 (permalink)  
Old 10-24-2007, 04:03 AM
Todd Allcock
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: iPhone is AT&T's top-selling handset

At 23 Oct 2007 09:06:01 -0700 Mr. Strat wrote:

> Just because someone sells a lot of something doesn't mean it's any
> good.


Unless it's an iPod, right?
You're quick to point out that sales isn't an indicator of quality when
it's a category that Apple has a small fraction of the market, like PC or
OS sales, yet the market dominance of the iPod is somehow "proof" of it's
greatness.

> The reason for Windows' success can be traced to early-day
> philosophies of the two companies.


Yes, one was sold as an add-on to any compatible device with an open
architecture, while one was bundled as a value-add only available for or
with higher-priced computers with a closed architecture from a single
vendor.

Knock the instability of Windows all you like, but it has a tough task-
it has to install, and work, on a myriad of essentially untested hardware
configurations from dozens, if not hundreds of vendors.

Is Mac OS stable? Sure- why shouldn't it be? It's written, tested, and
sold by the samea vendor who has built every single machine it's capable
of running on- no "mystery" configurations or "99% compatible" hardware
is lurking around waiting to trip it up- no incompatible vendor supplied
drivers or software to conflict with, etc.



Reply With Quote