View Single Post
  #13 (permalink)  
Old 01-15-2008, 10:20 PM
Joel Koltner
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: NEWS: Sony Develops New Close Proximity Wireless Transfer Technology "TransferJet"

"John Navas" <spamfilter1@navasgroup.com> wrote in message
news:sp8qo3holhbem3ih6k1gp60s5v97ph48k0@4ax.com...
> * New technology is good no matter where it comes from and no matter
> what the motive.


I can't believe you're serious about that.

> * Working within a standards process can be excruciatingly slow and
> difficult, which is why we have so many de facto standards.


Yes.

> * Sony is anything but alone in pushing its own technology wrinkles.
> All the "pre-N" Wi-Fi products are a notable case in point.


True, although I think that *most* pre-N manufacturers released their goods
just to gain market share but still fully intended to support the "real" N
standard (via a software upgrade) when it was fully ratified.

> * There are nice features in TransferJet not in Bluetooth 3.0 and
> Wireless USB; e.g., the very short range.


OK.

> * Bluetooth 3.0 and Wireless USB both have some significant issues.


All protocols do; there's no reason to believe that TransferJet will have
greater or fewer warts than USB or Bluetooth.

> * There's nothing wrong with Memory Stick, which has clear advantages
> over some other formats.


I guess I don't know what I'm missing with SD cards and CF? I agree there's
nothing wrong with Memory Stick, but I've never been attracted to it either --
it always cost noticeably more for the same storage than with other formats.

> * The market will ultimately decide the winner(s).


Yep.

> I'd much rather have wireless.


For something that works over all of 3cm, you might as well just have a
standardized docking port. iPods, ironically enough, have become a de-facto
docking port connector standard!



Reply With Quote