View Single Post
  #16 (permalink)  
Old 04-17-2008, 01:17 PM
Paul
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Can I replace my Nvidia Geforce 2 mx 200 with a new matrox milleniumG550?

HDI wrote:
> On 15 apr, 17:16, Paul <nos...@needed.com> wrote:
>> HDI wrote:
>>
>>> I've looked here in the shops for passively cooled agp dual monitor
>>> cards.
>>> What do you think of these (they have to handle at least a resolution
>>> of 1440x900):
>>> * Gigabyte Geforce 7600 GS 256 MB (GV-N76G256D-RH)
>>> Is the max power draw of 32 W too much for this computer?
>>> The interface is AGP 8X and my current one is AGP 4X. If my
>>> motherbord can handle only 4X will this work?
>>> * XFX GeForce 6200A 256 MB (PV-T44A-WANG)
>>> The second one is two times as expensive as the first one.

>> That one is an interesting mix of features. On the one hand, it has an external
>> power connector. (Usually a sign of slightly higher power consumption.)
>> The idea is, they wanted a source of +12V to run the power conversion,
>> without the limitations of the current carrying capabilities of the
>> pins on the AGP slot. On the other hand, the heatsink is passive (and
>> the heatsink is a bit larger than some of the other passively cooled
>> cards). I'd say this is a possible solution, as you don't plan to
>> use the 3D features, so it probably won't get that hot.
>>
>> GIGABYTE GeForce 7600GS GV-N76G256D-RH Video Cardhttp://c1.neweggimages.com/NeweggImage/productimage/14-125-039-09.jpg
>>
>> The 7600GS power varies between 14W and 28W or so, according to this
>> estimation (they used a 7600GT and downclocked it, to make the
>> measurement).
>>
>> http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/vid...r-noise_6.html
>>
>> You can read some of the review comments here. They mention the heatsink
>> runs pretty hot, so you may want to place a fan near the card. You can
>> connect a computer case fan to one of your motherboard fan headers, to get
>> a source of power for the fan.
>>
>> http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814125039
>>
>> The second card (PV-T44A-WANG) is apparently carried by Dell. A non-Dell
>> web site lists the price as being somewhere in the $50 USD range. A couple
>> places list it as out of stock, but may be arriving soon. This site lists
>> the card for $42.
>>
>> http://www.mwave.com/mwave/viewspec....iteria=3903480
>>
>> Judging by the size of the heatsink, the 6200 draws less power. Note that
>> the FX5200 AGP that I had a fan mounted next to, had the exact same kind
>> of heatsink as your 6200. So it still might need a fan, if there are
>> signs of instability.
>>
>> If you can find the 6200 card for a reasonable price, then that might
>> run a bit cooler. If you don't want to deal with Internet sellers, then
>> get the 7600GS card. You'll need to provide a source of power to the 7600GS,
>> to the four pin Molex on the end of the card. If your power supply doesn't
>> have any spare Molex power connectors, you can use a "Y cable" to make
>> another connector for it. (Some video cards, like my ATI 9800Pro, included a
>> Y cable for power.) There is a female and two male connectors, and allows
>> extending power from the back of a disk drive. I've used quite a few
>> of these, for my computers, for one thing and another. I've also used
>> them to power fans.
>>
>> http://c1.neweggimages.com/NeweggIma...201-006-02.jpg
>>
>> The 7600GS won't use its maximum power, unless you are doing stuff
>> involving 3D. Games are something that uses 3D. Vista also does a
>> bit of 3D (Aero interface, compositing of windows etc). Perhaps an
>> application that uses OpenGL, would kick the card into 3D mode as
>> well.
>>
>> Some video cards support user adjustment of core and memory clocks.
>> If you want to further reduce the power consumption of a card, then
>> turning down the clocks being used on the card, is one way to do it.
>>
>> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RivaTuner
>>
>> In terms of installing the card, this is what I'd recommend.
>>
>> 1) Make sure you have a driver to install on the new card. There should
>> be a CD in the box. You can also download a more recent driver from
>> the Internet before you start work.
>> 2) Uninstall the existing driver for the MX200. Check Add/Remove control
>> panel, and look for the Nvidia driver.
>> 3) Shut down and remove power from the computer. Change video cards.
>> 4) On bootup, the new card will operate in a vanilla VGA mode.
>> Install the new Nvidia driver. After a reboot, you should be offered
>> more output resolutions, and be able to set up the display properly.
>> 5) If the card runs too hot (either behaves unstable, or you burn yourself
>> on the heatsink), then either you can experiment with Rivatuner or
>> you can purchase a case cooling fan, and fit that next to the card,
>> blowing on the heatsink.
>>
>> If you need a fan, this is an example. I have one of the larger Vantec
>> fans, and it is pretty quiet. This one is 80mm square, and 27 CFM.
>> It is pictured with a Molex power connector, so if you purchased
>> yet another Molex Y cable, both this fan and the 7600GS power connector,
>> could run off an existing disk drive power cable.
>>
>> http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16811999602
>>
>> Finding a bracket to hold a fan, can actually be difficult. I made
>> my own bracket, using a piece of aluminum from the hardware store
>> (L shaped cross section). This is an example of a retail kit, that
>> could hold a fan where it is needed. This kit would allow positioning
>> a fan next to a video card (but takes up a slot or more).
>>
>> http://www.logisyscomputer.com/views...s/CF108_13.jpg (picture)
>>
>> There are also complete heatsink replacements for video cards, but
>> fitting cards that have an HSI bridge, is a bit more difficult. (Cooling
>> kits don't always fit AGP cards.) And the replacement coolers also make
>> your overall video card purchase a lot more expensive than it should be.
>> This is an example of one.
>>
>> Here, someone is fitting a VF700 to their video card. The blue heatsink
>> covers the HSI chip. The problem with this, is the top edge of the
>> VF700, can bump into the side panel on the computer case. The video
>> card in this case, is a 6600GT AGP, a 50W card.
>>
>> http://img163.imageshack.us/img163/9413/660029to.jpg
>>
>> http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/vid...sumption2006_7....
>>
>> HTH,
>> Paul- Tekst uit oorspronkelijk bericht niet weergeven -
>>
>> - Tekst uit oorspronkelijk bericht weergeven -

>
> Another problem: When I look at the resolutions supported 1440 x 900
> isn't in the list.
>
> Maybe I have to start all over and thinking of getting a new power
> supply.


For the 7600GS, this is the Gigabyte web page.

http://www.gigabyte.com.tw/Products/...ProductID=2334

Gigabyte has a link at the bottom of the page, listing resolutions. Page 2
has the resolution you are looking for.

http://www.gigabyte.com.tw/FileList/...dard_modes.pdf

*******

This is the page for PV-T44A-WANG, the 6200a. There isn't really any
reassurances of what modes are supported here.

http://www.xfxforce.com/web/product/...rationId=79772

If I look at the release notes of the latest Nvidia driver release -

http://us.download.nvidia.com/Window...ease_Notes.pdf

On page 50 is a list of cards and their combined resolution options. The
top of page 54 lists this:

1440 x 900 32 60 70 72 75 85 100 120 140 144 150 170 200

That is 1440x900 in 32 bit color, at refresh rates from 60 to 200. Now,
we know that this is an analog specification (because the digital wouldn't
support refresh that high), so that specification is what the VGA
connector is capable of. The digital DVI specification should not support
quite as high a refresh rate.

So I cannot say I have 100% assurance that both analog and digital support
that resolution on the 6200A, because the release notes document doesn't
present the resolution information as nicely as the Gigabyte document
does. It probably does, but I cannot guarantee it.

Paul

Reply With Quote